Travel Diary 7 17 Oct 2009 So yesterday was a full day. I attended a talk by Tony Coady, coincidentally of my alma mater Melbourne, on whether religion is a danger. He argued, well, I thought, that it was no more a danger than any other human activity. However, one of the ways he did that was to suggest there is a “pure religion”, citing the Epistle of James, that evades the political and social corruption, and that is why religion is not a danger (I am unfairly compressing a complex and sophisticated argument here). In my question I suggested that this was to define the problem away, and that the only sensible approach was to empirically look at the correlations (he had cited some sociological studies that argued that the religious were no more likely to commit acts of violence than anyone else), and not to make a priori arguments either way. Then a mad rush to London by bus, where I finally located my B&B stay in Chelsea, and rushed to meet David Williams, my friend who is a botanist and systematist at the Natural History Museum, at a local train station, from whence we found a nice Italian restaurant, and ate and drank. And drank. And then we went to a local pub and drank. By the end of the night I was feeling no pain. I hope I didn’t say anything I shouldn’t have. Probably did. Dave and I talked about lots of things, ranging from Leon Croizat, to the cladistics revolution, to Dostoevsky, to smoking. It was a great evening, and I’m glad we got together, although I always seem to have too short a time with him when we meet. Right now I’m sitting in Heathrow waiting for the internet to work. I’ve tried four providers and each one hangs when the login screen comes up, buggrit. Ah… got one…. Administrative Epistemology Politics Religion
Epistemology 3QD Philosophy prize 4 Sep 2010 The 3QuarksDaily website is running its second Prize in Philosophy which has a convenient wrap up of some good philosophy posts. Most of them, though, are your usual deep ethics, metaphysics and epistemology, which is too deep for the likes of me. Still, you may find them worth reading and… Read More
Administrative At last! A Macbook! 22 Jan 2009 If I have seemed a little distracted and unresponsive lately it’s because I have been using an old clunker of a half dead laptop. I received my new employ’s Macbook yesterday and spent pretty much the rest of the day migrating to the new beast. I’m still in the process… Read More
Epistemology tautology 1a: corrections 21 Aug 2009 So Gary Nelson reminded me of his paper on “The Two Wallaces” (2009) in which he points out that Wallace used the tautology argument himself, and responded to criticisms as early as 1873. Wallace also used the term “fitness” in a general sense. Read More
I enjoyed Coady’s book on testimony, which I read back when I was trying to write a dissertation on social epistemology.