So much to say, so little time 9 Jul 2009 As I prepare for the conferences I start attending and blathering at from tomorrow, I of course find a treasure trove of things to blog about. Since I can’t really do them all justice, I will merely put a one liner for each below the fold. Mark Pallen’s paper on the myth of Annie’s death causing Darwin’s atheism is now up online. Read it; it’s a marvellous piece of detective work. What he doesn’t say is that what motivates the myth is the notion of some historians that people don’t actually make their intellectual decisions for intellectual reasons, whereas he is taking Darwin more or less at his word. Bite Size Biology has a nice piece on the underappreciated and overdemonised Haeckel. Epiphenom discusses the inverse relationship between a nation’s “social health” and its religiosity. AK’s Rambling Thoughts has a very nice discussion of the origin and meaning of “central nervous system”. My hero Frans de Waal attacks “anthropodenial” – the claim that humans are nothing at all like animals in cognition, in a letter in Nature which is unfortunately behind a paywall. Tim Leonard has more on Hofstadter’s attack on “social Darwinism” at History of Economics Playground. And Anne-Marie Hodge at Endless Forms has a piece on a hybrid salamander that is supplanting the local native species because, among other things, it eats the young of that native species. Have fun. I’ll blog from the conferences when I can. Biology Evolution History Philosophy Science Social evolution Species and systematics Species concept Systematics
Philosophy My Absent Career 5: Two Davids 9 Dec 20221 Jan 2023 Sometime around 1994, I was finishing my computing diploma and got access to a unix terminal. Typing various commands assigned to us, I mistyped something and instead typed rn and what came up was the mother of all chat boards, which I later found out was called USENET, but which… Read More
Censorship Goodbye freedom 10 Sep 201113 Sep 2011 Ten years ago tomorrow tonight I was watching an episode of West Wing, and, as I do, channel surfing during the ads. One channel showed a fire in the World Trade Centre, which less than a month earlier I had stood at the base of looking up like the Australian… Read More
Creationism and Intelligent Design Paper withdrawn from Synthese 30 Apr 2011 Massimo Pigliucci, head of the Philosophy Program at City University of New York, and Raphael Scholl from the Department of Philosophy at the University of Bern, have withdrawn a paper from Synthese. Here, with their permission, is the text of the letter they sent to the editors in chief: To… Read More
Thanks for the plug. I’m hopeful that this one, and the companion piece on Cnidarians, will shake the tree a bit regarding evolutionary paradigms.
re: the Pallen link, there’s a very good essay by Proust, Contre Sainte-Beuve (Against Sainte-Beuve, for those with even less French than me) that attacks the whole idea that you can know more about a text by knowing about the author and his life. Proust attacks Sainte-Beuve (and the Goncourts) pretty vehemently for basing their lit crit on cosy little chats with salon authors, and bits of literary gossip. Looked for an online version, but can’t find any. There’s a good English edition available in print though.