Back in the saddle 16 Jul 2009 So, my conferencing has finished, and I’ve even managed to catch up on some sleep. The Ish conference was amazing: I got to hear a lot of papers on topics I am working on and I got to meet some of the people whose work has strongly influenced me, especially Phillip Sloan, a historian of biology, and Paul Farber, who was so far as I can tell the first critic of the essentialism myth. It’s a buzz to meet one’s heroes and even better to find they are great folk. There were some thought provoking talks on the species problem, on taxonomy, and general issues of essentialism, which all seem to be undergoing a bit of a revival, quite rightly. Of course, only I am right… I got quite grumpy about a repetition of the old caricatures of pattern cladism and of the views of people who I know and respect and deserve better, rather than reiterating the canards of old. But even that was fun; a good grump is good for the soul. Somehow – I’m not entirely sure – I got tapped for some committee work, not a day after I was boasting to a friend that I would never do committee work again. The gods are nothing if not ironic. I have a bit of work to do, but I’ll return with the usual garbage later on. Administrative Species and systematics Species concept
Ecology and Biodiversity What is “life”, again? 8 Sep 200718 Sep 2017 Now we turn to the modern accounts of life. In 1828, Friedrich Wöhler produced uric acid without using “kidney of man or dog”. Prior to that time, there was considered to be something different between organic chemistry and inorganic chemistry. Living things had some “vital fluid” that other things lacked…. Read More
Biology Jefferson on classification 17 Oct 201217 Oct 2012 The following letter, from this site with permission, was written by Thomas Jefferson in 1814. Apart from demonstrating how low American political life has fallen from its high commencement point, Jefferson shows he was up on the latest disputes in taxonomy. It was written to a Dr John Manners. The opinion… Read More
Epistemology Bayes, evolutionary clocks, and biogeography 30 Mar 20122 Apr 2012 I just received a review by Gareth Nelson of Michael Heads’ book Molecular Panbiogeography of the Tropics (publishers’ site). I should have blogged this before, since I got a copy, being on the editorial board for this series (the same one I published with at Uni Calif Press), but I have… Read More
Sounds like it was a great meeting. Like essentialism, pattern cladism is another myth very popular all the way from philosophers to systematic biologists: everything perceived as wrongheaded is automatically associated (blamed on) with pattern cladism. It is also not surprising that both myths are intertwined. Anyways, we miss you in the blogosphere so GET YOUR ACT TOGETHER MAN!
Thanks, Roberto. I am thinking that I might start writing a book on the philosophy of classification. It seems to be needed. I’m getting my act together and taking it on the road!
Farber, Paul Lawrence. 1976. The type-concept in zoology during the first half of the nineteenth century. Journal of the History of Biology 9 (1):93-119. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/BF00129174