Monthly Archives: August 2009

Book review: Evidence and Evolution

For those of you who have access to Systematic Biology, my review is here. It is online only so far. Elliot Sober’s book is by far the hardest book I have ever had to review, being one of the most … Continue reading

Comments Off

Filed under Book, Creationism and Intelligent Design, Epistemology, Evolution, Philosophy, Science

Tautology 4: What is a tautology?

So, what is the problem, philosophically speaking, with something in science being a tautology?

9 Comments

Filed under Epistemology, Philosophy

Tautology 3: The problem spreads

This post will look at two different aspects of the tautology problem: 1. The public aspect, as it becomes a widely used counterargument to “Darwinism”, and the rebuttals of some public “Darwinists”; and 2. How it played out in the … Continue reading

5 Comments

Filed under Biology, Creationism and Intelligent Design, Epistemology, Evolution, Metaphysics, Philosophy, Science

In the mind of a microbial paper

Over at Small Things Considered is a point by point explanation and explication of a recent paper. For us nonscientists it’s a useful guide to how papers come to be written, how techniques and subjects are chosen, and so forth. … Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under Biology

On Grayling on the Jesuits

A long time ago I would debate the local Jesuits over scotch, when I was still a Christian theology student. I learned two things: 1. those guys could really hold their liquor (I drank much more sparingly); and 2. Jesuits … Continue reading

24 Comments

Filed under History, Philosophy, Religion, Science

Sorry for the repeats

The intarwubs failed me; something to do with a rogue DNS between me and WordPress. So I have deleted the older versions of each post.

Comments Off

Filed under Administrative

Tautology 2: The problem arises

After Williams and others had made the comment that fitness is a tautology, it came around that the point needed to be discussed in more detail. One such discussion was by a student of Dobzhansky’s, Richard Lewontin.

8 Comments

Filed under Creationism and Intelligent Design, Evolution, Metaphysics, Philosophy, Science

Rudiments and vestiges

A new paper has just come out on the functionality of the human appendix, or cecum (caecum in British biology). The authors, following some work done on appendix function in 2006, have said that the caecum in humans has a … Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under Evolution, Philosophy, Species and systematics, Systematics

The weekend in crazy

See the One Hour Parking Show. And the Washington Post…

Comments Off

Filed under Humor, Politics

Time wasting

Sometimes I am asked why they, the questioner, should bother with philosophical questions. I am often at a loss to say why, because it is so damned obvious to me we must address the metaquestions. So I was pleased to … Continue reading

5 Comments

Filed under Philosophy